The following is based on your complainant’s review of the reports of other officers and your complainant’s own investigation: April 22 (25-011263) On the afternoon of April 22, 2025, Maplewood Police responded to Discount Tires, [ADDRESS REDACTED]. N., on a report of theft that had occurred that day. On arrival, a manager said that a man in a white van had stolen several tires from the back of the building. Surveillance video was recovered. It shows a man arriving in a white van. He exits, grabs four tires one-on- one and quickly throws each of them into the van.
He then drives away, as employees begin to run after him on foot (25-011263). Each of the stolen tires had an approximate retail value of $400, for a total loss of $1,600. October 20 (25-029895) About six months later, on October 21, officers were called back to the same business on a similar report. A manager said that the man had returned the prior afternoon (October 20) and stolen more tires. Surveillance video was recovered from October 20. It shows the white van returning, this time driven by an unknown person (who never exits). A figure appearing to be the same man as in April exits and again grabs four tires.
He quickly throws them into the van, which then drives away. As in April, each of the stolen tires had an approximate retail value of $400, for a total loss of $1,600. Identification and Criminal History Among the registered owners of the van is the defendant, DANIEL MATHIAS CONROY ([DOB REDACTED]). He is a physical match for the man seen stealing the tires in the videos. In August 2025 (between the two thefts), the defendant pled guilty to felony Aid / Abet Identity Theft; sentencing is scheduled for February 20, 2026 (Case No. ••-CR-••-••••). The defendant’s criminal record includes an October 2025 felony conviction for Financial Transaction Card Fraud.
He faces a pending felony charge of Theft by Swindle (Case No. ••-CR-••-••••). Officers have been unable to locate the defendant or the van. An investigator left a message for the defendant at his phone number but did not receive a response.
